Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

What does having value or interest to you have to do with intelligence?
 help



What does IQ have to do with intelligence?

(Please forgive the flippant response. I believe it cuts to the core of what the parent was intending.)


Is it a serious question? IQ tries to quantify the positive correlation between the results of all intellectual tasks a person takes (AKA positive manifold).

It is, but it was also a rhetorical device!

I wanted to highlight that we're actually looking at a trio of concepts: intelligence, IQ, and value. Strongly correlated concepts, yes, but also meaningfully distinct!


Whatever the people who came up with IQ intended isn’t really relevant to the question of whether IQ measures intellect. At best is is loosely correlated. Very loosely.

IQ strongly correlates with many real world outcomes that people tend to associate with being more "intellectual".

IQ has precise definition. It's what the tests measure. Intellect has only fuzzy handwavey definition. Correlation between IQ and intellect is about as loose as the definition of the intellect. The way people make the correlation even looser is by defining intellect in even more fuzzy and nebulous manner.


OK. Demonstrate it. BTW, you can easily read critiques of "The mismeasure of Man" if you want to.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: